Skip to main content

Get Out: A Legacy of Trauma and the Medical System

 

Unfortunately, the recent horror/comedy movie Get Out, written by Jordan Peele, only scratched the surface regarding the real exploitation and experimentation of people of color within the medical and psychological industrial complexes.

This history has purposely been hidden but the historical and present day impacts are still with us. Mainly, the high levels of distrust of the medical system on behalf of many people of color and the high health disparities influenced by the lack of cultural diversity and racial justice.

These two factors in turn influence access and utilization, chronic disease management and overall health equity.

The following are multiple instances throughout recent history wherein people of color were utilized as literal guinea pigs in order to advance medical research and profit gain: 

IMG_1241

— The father of gynecology, J. Marion Sims, used the reproductive systems of enslaved black women who developed health issues due to forced intercourse and forced childbirth to further his medical research and develop surgical processes and instruments.

IMG_1242

 — The psychological industrial complex thrived off of the sharecropping and "chain-gang" system. With unlimited access to poor blacks trapped in poverty, early psychiatrists would perform forced lobotomies on innocent individuals, leaving them incapacitated afterwards. Presently, the pharmecutical industry is wreaking havoc on marginalized communities due to the lack of ethnic pharmacology. 

IMG_1243

— Tuskegee experiments, where dozens of black men were willingly untreated and willingly injected with syphillis for researchers to study how the disease destroys the body. Many of these men died or developed psychological disorders.

IMG_1244
— Forced sterilization. After reconstruction, white scientists developed the American Eugenics Society in order to spread pseudoscience about genetic inferiority among black and brown peoples. They developed standardized tests that they used against people of color in order to sterilize them and even dumped birth control into the water supplies of minority communities to eliminate reproduction.

IMG_1245

— Henrietta lacks, a poor black woman from the 1940s south who was denied proper medical treatment and ended up dying from late stage cervical cancer. Her cells were stolen from her body without permission and ended up furthering the fields of genetics, cancer research and genetics because her cells were literally immortal and allowed doctors and scientists to facilitate research that was previously impossible.

In short, the medical system itself is a form of trauma for marginalized communities. From the emphasis on profit to the emphasis on scientific breakthrough, marginalized communities are constantly caught in the crosshairs of systemic racism and capitalism.

For us to achieve health equity we must realize this system is doing EXACTLY what it was designed to do and will never be able to appropriately serve marginalized communities appropriately. 

Eliminating trauma within the medical system and achieving health disparities must be two-fold:

  1. Develop community-based and community-lead solutions
  2. Develop a long-term plan for dismantling the inherent and reoccurring themes of exploitation, experimentation and exclusion within the medical system itself. 

Attachments

Images (5)
  • IMG_1241
  • IMG_1242
  • IMG_1243
  • IMG_1244
  • IMG_1245

Add Comment

Comments (5)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Incidentally, that Facebook site I mentioned is here

https://www.facebook.com/groups/166671503346266/

and a frequent contributor is Australian psychiatrist Dr Rob Purssey -- especially check out his views on how psychoactive medication really works  -- he's worth his weight in gold!

Thank you for posting this, Daisy. So grim, and I agree with your conclusions in how to change the medical system. I'd also add that people in the medical system -- and in any system -- integrate practices based on ACEs science, the first of which is to understand how their own ACEs and resilience factors shaped their lives, so that we evolve into understanding that there is no them and us when it comes to figuring out how to create a system that is self-healing and helps us all heal.

Daisy,

Thank you for sharing this powerful post.  I would imagine the vast majority of Black people know about The Tuskegee Study of Untreated Syphilis in the Negro Male (aka The Tuskegee Experiment), the sadistic experiments of Sims (the progenitor of American gynecology), forced sterilization of Black female prisoners and medicaid recipients, and so on.  I would also imagine that historical knowledge, and personal/vicarious experiences with discrimination in the health care system (and life) negatively affects the sense of trust and safety for some Black patients.  Likewise, this knowledge and experience may consciously and subconsciously affect a Black patient's willingness to access care and/or follow through on recommendations/referrals.  It seems grossly insufficient to just know this medical trauma happened, still happens, and some of the these people and their children/families are still alive...living the legacy of these actions.  A conversation about resilience as the go to treatment seems inappropriate.  

How would you suggest we use this knowledge of cultural-historical context and understanding of contemporary negative impacts to address this trauma at the patient, practitioner, and systems level?  

Thank you for your engagement and being willing to approach difficult and necessary conversations. 

Last edited by Pamela Denise Long

I think it's pretty unfair to lump "psychological" into the industrial complexes responsible for this brutality - - - I'm a retired psychologist - - except in New Zealand, where this problem applies in spades. It's really the psychiatrict / pharmacological industrial complex - - if you know that Facebook site - - but  like "Critical Psychiatry" there's a couple of great psychiatrists / medicos contributing to the site. 

In New Zealand, Psychology is the very obedient lapdog of psychiatry - - again, self-interest reins supreme, over patient welfare. 

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×