Skip to main content

High ACE'd Adult Advisory Group?

In response to prior discussions and MEM's question today.

 

I propose a forum for high ACE scoring adults looking to brainstorm, discuss, vent and share.  Many of us have discussed this before and imagined possible style and formats and functions. I did mention this to Jane ahead of time. She was not opposed to it being housed/connected here or offsite and independently.

 

Many organizations are starting to pay attention to trauma-informed, trauma-sensitive, trauma-compassionate policies, programs and initiatives. So many are becoming aware of the ACE study, ACE scores and it's wonderful and exciting.


It could be the perfect time to have a diverse group of people with high ACE scores to speak to the lived experience and to at least be able to offer insights, thoughts, opinions and experiences on initiatives, goals and plans.

 

When it comes to treatment for post-traumatic stress, especially developmental trauma, there is no such advisory group of impacted people who are advocates, rate or review treatment approaches and have a united front though many of us speak individually, write, blog, speak or are involved with other advocate groups which touch on many overlapping issues.

 

To be discussed:

 

  • Interest in a group
  • Name of the group
  • Members: What is considered a "high" ACE score? Is it the "4 or higher as that's "when things get serious" as Dr. Filetti said in one of the videos on You Tube or the 6 or higher number that is associated with the 19 years early mortality? And what about the added ACES since the original 10?
  • Function of Group: White paper policy style? Peer support? Ratings and reviews of treatments, policies and protocols and how impactful, effective or on target we view them as?
  • Resource Building When Prevention is Too Late (we've talked about book lists and therapies or healing modalities that have/haven't worked personally)

I could give 1.5 hours twice a month to have conference calls/working meetings to keep moving a plan or initiative ahead if we agree this should happen. It would be nice to collect some of the information sharing we've done online and privately in emails, dialogues, that are from those with lived experiences.

 

Of course, many of us work in fields where we can or do bring ACE awareness with us and work to implement what we know and have learned through research or personally. Some of us are "out" about it and some aren't or are in some places and not in others. An advisory group might allow us a united voice without necessarily having everyone use full names if professionally or personally uncomfortable doing so.

 

I'm opening up the discussion which can be moved off line as well for privacy as well as to Facebook where there are private groups (post content can't be seen) or secret groups (membership can't be seen).

 

I'm a single mom and find without meetings and structure and collaboration it's hard to get stuff out of the idea stage. At least I know that is true for myself!

 

Let me know what you all think.

Thanks,
Cissy

And perhaps we could have a conference call once a week maybe at 7:00 p.m. Eastern every other Weds?

 

 

 

 

 

 

Add Comment

Comments (24)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

Hello Crissy, I would like to join this discussion.  I am a clinician and administrator who has been through a host of trauma focused trainings and am responsible to train our Behavioral Health Division in the Sanctuary Model.  I have a high ACE score (depending on screening tool) and am always feeling like I need more support in figuring out how to manage it all while being an effective agent of change, health and healing. 

Please share whatever insights are available on how to connect with this group.

I would be in support of this and add that it would be equally helpful to track resilience factors, health issues, quality of life, relationships etc. associated with our ACE's to help us and others determine what helps and hinders our ability to have a good quality of life despite ACE scores.

In the research I've conducted with high risk expectant mothers and in school-based health centers I've noticed that there is no correlation between ACE and GAF scores-meaning that one kid might get completely knocked down by a single ACE event, while a women with all 10 is actually doing considerably well in life.

Short answer-Yes!

Hi all - 

Christine, I think what you've suggested is a great idea! I'd love to participate in the group. I work with young children, from birth to 5 years old, in Head Start (3,4,5) and Early Head Start (infants and toddlers, birth to 3) settings. I have a high ACE score myself, and am passionate about protecting young children. I'm very impressed with everyone who is contributing to ACEs Connection/ACEs Too High, etc. I live in Siskiyou County, CA, which is the Northernmost county, bordering Oregon. It is one of the largest sized (geographically),  most sparsely populated, and poorest counties in CA, and the population centers are quite spread out. We have a very committed, dedicated Early Childhood Provider community, but so fat the only people in it that I've met that know what ACEs stands for - are people who heard about it from me. My long-term goal is to bring a lot more awareness about childhood trauma, trauma in general, and other such things to the county... 

Tina,
I think a private group is a great idea too. We may choose to share in a more public forum or to have views shared without names but it would be nice for some of the sharing to be done privately. Secret groups on Facebook do I allow for that so I think that could be a place to start.
Cissy
 
Originally Posted by Tina Marie Hahn, MD:

And I would really like a private group.  I guess I don't care if what I have to contribute gets out in some way somehow later, personally, but I would like a private discussion because I want to really discuss why some traditional therapies did not work and were actually harmful for me and be able to feel freely open to discuss why......

 

I may seem "out" but I'm not really "out".   I think many of us can offer so much more when we can truly feel safe (or relatively so) to speak our truths.....

 

 

 

Robert,
I'll keep you posted. I think I'll make a Facebook page as well (private and also secret for those who want total privacy. I really feel passionate about a high ACE scoring contingent having a place to voice opinions, state some policy suggestions, brainstorm and share and support one another. Of course we are not all the same. But, it's nice to have a voice of our own especially while there is good focus and attention on ACES. Hopefully this will give you a place to participate as well.
Cissy
Originally Posted by Robert Olcott:

     When Vermont passed their HB 762, requiring All Vermont health care providers to screen All patients [regardless of age] for ACEs, one of our ACEsConnection members there was working on rewording some of the questions. 

     I saw an 18 question ACEs form on the World Health Organization's (WHO) site, broken down into further clarifying sub-questions in each of the eighteen categories. The WHO ACE International Questionaire does not have 18 questions, as I recall, but I seem to recall "Less ambiguous wording"...

     Where the US CDC/Kaiser ACE questionaire asks if a "household member" was incarcerated, it doesn't specify whether it is an adolescent or adult member of the household. When I was an "emancipated minor", still in High School, and working to pay for my own apartment - no longer part of my "family-of-origin's" household, I experienced "homelessness", prior to getting my own apartment.....and "incarceration", prior to , and after graduation. 

     I may not be able to participate in the initial ACEs Conference call[s], but I'm very much interested in both supporting and participating in this endeavor.

 

Wonderful! I agree the support is crucial and wonderful and I'm so thankful for it and the setting and environment and work you and team here does!
Originally Posted by Jane Stevens:

Cissy -- Yes, the group Childhood Disrupted will be on ACEsConnection. We're in the process of adding information and inviting people now. I'll announce in the weekly roundup. 

 

I'm continually amazed at all the wonderful people who are doing such incredible work in spreading the word about ACEs, and how they support each other!

 

Cheers, Jane

 

     When Vermont passed their HB 762, requiring All Vermont health care providers to screen All patients [regardless of age] for ACEs, one of our ACEsConnection members there was working on rewording some of the questions. 

     I saw an 18 question ACEs form on the World Health Organization's (WHO) site, broken down into further clarifying sub-questions in each of the eighteen categories. The WHO ACE International Questionaire does not have 18 questions, as I recall, but I seem to recall "Less ambiguous wording"...

     Where the US CDC/Kaiser ACE questionaire asks if a "household member" was incarcerated, it doesn't specify whether it is an adolescent or adult member of the household. When I was an "emancipated minor", still in High School, and working to pay for my own apartment - no longer part of my "family-of-origin's" household, I experienced "homelessness", prior to getting my own apartment.....and "incarceration", prior to , and after graduation. 

     I may not be able to participate in the initial ACEs Conference call[s], but I'm very much interested in both supporting and participating in this endeavor.

Last edited by Robert Olcott

Cissy -- Yes, the group Childhood Disrupted will be on ACEsConnection. We're in the process of adding information and inviting people now. I'll announce in the weekly roundup. 

 

I'm continually amazed at all the wonderful people who are doing such incredible work in spreading the word about ACEs, and how they support each other!

 

Cheers, Jane

And I would really like a private group.  I guess I don't care if what I have to contribute gets out in some way somehow later, personally, but I would like a private discussion because I want to really discuss why some traditional therapies did not work and were actually harmful for me and be able to feel freely open to discuss why......

 

I may seem "out" but I'm not really "out".   I think many of us can offer so much more when we can truly feel safe (or relatively so) to speak our truths.....

 

 

Last edited by Former Member
Jane,
That will be an interesting group. I admire Donna's work and her book is going to help so many more learn about ACEs.
Will that discussion happen here ? That will certainly be powerful. It will be great to have info. sharing and access to all of that info. for everyone. I can see the benefit of it being public.
 
And I can see the power of having a private group as well for those with high ACE scores to speak to issues as a group with lived experiences as well as professional experiences.
 
It's such an exciting time. You must be so amazed by so much of the work, networking and collaborations you help make happen!
 
Cissy

Thank you so much for organizing this, Cissy.

 

There might be the opportunity to have some of these conversations on a new group that's forming -- it's called Childhood Disrupted, and its impetus is Donna Jackson Nakazawa's book, Childhood Disrupted: How Your Biography Becomes Your Biology and How You Can Heal. She and her assistant have offered to help moderate it. It's a place for discussing the effects of childhood adversity and what people are doing to heal. 

 

Of course, it won't be a private group. I'm a big advocate of people being as open as possible about ACEs, because that's the way that we can accelerate resources to prevent them. But I'm also cognizant that it takes time for people to be comfortable with discussing their ACEs in a public forum.

 

So, there might be room for both types of groups: public and private. 

 

And I like to add witnessing violence against any family member, and homelessness in the parents or in the teen.  (and I can now confidently say after looking at Dr. Burke Harris questions that yes I do indeed have 10 ACEs plus several other of the additional -- that really wasn't necessary but I like to affirm me sometimes). 

Thank you so much for organizing this, Cissy.

 

There might be the opportunity to have some of these conversations on a new group that's forming -- it's called Childhood Disrupted, and its impetus is Donna Jackson Nakazawa's book, Childhood Disrupted: How Your Biography Becomes Your Biology and How You Can Heal. She and her assistant have offered to help moderate it. It's a place for discussing the effects of childhood adversity and what people are doing to heal. 

 

Of course, it won't be a private group. I'm a big advocate of people being as open as possible about ACEs, because that's the way that we can accelerate resources to prevent them. But I'm also cognizant that it takes time for people to be comfortable with discussing their ACEs in a public forum.

 

So, there might be room for both types of groups: public and private. 

Looks like some great initial enthusiasm. We can start with a conference call. 

 

Anyone want to add to the agenda? 

 

I think we could do a round table style meeting and everyone spend a few minutes saying what they'd personally want in a general way, recorded for minutes, and then hit the specific agenda items. 

 

Anyone like to do minutes?

 

Anyone got a good free con call service they like?

 

Cissy

When I used the wording/language on the first World Health Organization ACE International Questionaire, to calculate my score, it's about 5 points higher, than when I use the wording on the US CDC/Kaiser ACE questionaire....

It bears a faint resemblance to one administered at my primary [health] care provider, 14-15 years ago, but I was just asked the questions by a [dual] Resident physician (Internal Med/Psychiatry) reading them to me from a computer screen the resident was typing/entering the data at...possibly developed by Stanley Rosenberg, M.D.-a [trauma-informed] doc at Dartmouth Psychiatric Research Center. My primary care clinic had recently been bought out by Dartmouth-Hitchcock Clinic.

Post
Copyright Ā© 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×