Skip to main content

American Police and Prisons Are Failing the Mentally Ill [PSMag.com]

 

Earlier this month, police received a frantic phone call from the parents of Melissa Boarts. Their daughter had just threatened to slit her wrists, they explained to the police, and had then promptly driven off. Police allege that, when they caught up with Boarts, who was diagnosed with bipolar manic depression, she got out of her car, “armed with a weapon and charged the officers.” Officers shot and killed her. In the wake of their daughter’s death, Boarts’ parents have been adamant about one thing, the Montgomery Advertiser reports: “They didn’t have to shoot her.”

Boarts’ case is one of hundreds that demonstrates the injustice plaguing those with mental disorders, including those with drug and alcohol problems, at every point in the American criminal justice system. Often, these are individuals who should have been receiving therapy for their ailments. Instead, because mental-health programs are underfunded, they end up in jail or prison for crimes—such as disorderly conduct or threatening behavior—that can be traced to their untreated illness, experts argue. Once incarcerated, individuals must then deal with staffers who haven’t received proper training and thus often use unnecessary force with mentally ill inmates who don’t adhere to the rules.



[For more of this story, written by Francie Diep, go to https://psmag.com/american-pol...135262c27#.dfwies9i2]

Add Comment

Comments (2)

Newest · Oldest · Popular

     Over 45 years ago, Adult [youthful offenders were also housed there] Inmates at a [N.Y.] county penitentiary {which had no indoor plumbing/just buckets}, had the Chaplain deliver a petition from them, to the County Sheriff, asking that a mentally ill adult male prisoner be moved to the local state hospital, as they had witnessed guards mistreating the man. The man later ended up in a basement dungeon solitary cell during the Christmas holiday, and the guards in question had continued to mistreat him in that area, sliding his food tray across a floor covered in fecal material.

Discipline instead of punitive punishment.  When did punitive punishment stop being seen as a crime?  It is the leading cause of mental illness, aside from the food we eat.  It's called beating someone when they are already down.  Caring for people even when we don't deserve it.  It works for our kids and it works for our neighbors.  Until we can treat all people with infinite worth, we will continue to damage the people we see hurting and struggling.  Stop the abuse, and take responsibility for being professionals.  Professionals should be able to care for others better than everyday citizens, but there is a lack of understanding for how we define a professional.  Any Judge, Officer, Therapist, Doctor, Child Welfare Worker, Teacher, etc. can make the difference.  Us and Them is our crime. 


WE should stop letting our differences divide us, and appreciate that we need each other, and without a solid foundation we will be at the bottom of our problems.  Every person given the right ingredients will either succeed or fail.  We are the only species on the planet that depends on relationship for our brains to develop.  Be the difference!  It starts with each of us individually.  Who is the one person you have invested in regardless of their effort.  When we stop attaching our expectations to our acts of kindness, we start to see results, but not if we expect and force an outcome. Best wishes in standing up for and standing with the broken and hurting.

Post
Copyright © 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×