Skip to main content

Dear all,

 

For a research project on how trauma-informed and supportive elementary school teachers are towards students exposed to chronic stress, i am interested in measuring the teachers' basic empathy levels. We think that the results of our proposed intervention might be influenced by inherently present levels of empathy of the teachers. Is there a valid, and preferably quick instrument available, for this purpose? 

Would love to hear about any instruments, promising research studies or other pointers you might have. Thanks in advance!

 

Kind regards,

Tim Mulder

Child abuse and neglect sector, The Netherlands

Original Post

Replies sorted oldest to newest

Hi Tim,

 

I personally don't have any experience with concrete tools for measuring empathy in that field, but I would like to implement such a tool (or several) into an (open source) online ACE Toolkit I'm developing, as it's a very relevant tool.

 

From a little googling, I found the article "Measuring Empathy" from Stanford and "Empathy Tests and Measures" from Center for Building a Culture of Empathy, but I cannot judge the relevancy in relation to your requirements.

 

Anyway, if possible, let me know what you discover, as it would be great to identify and implement such tools in the toolkit - for the benefit of everyone.

 

Best, 

Thomas

People who don't have empathy for the most part do not have eye contact with the person they are talking to. They are also ready to move on before the other person is finished talking. They hear but they don't listen. They also become the reference point for things that are said rather than trying to get the other persons perspective.

 

I know what it feels like to grow up without empathy. It makes you feel small, insignificant and lonely, even in a crowded room. I made this short video about empathy to share with others the hurt a lack of empathy can bring to others.

 

 

 

 

 

Attachments

Videos (1)
Empathy of Self
Last edited by Janie Lancaster

Hello Thomas,

Thank you for your reply. The two links you provided were indeed helpful in my search, although i yet have to find the right combination of validity of the questionnaire v.s. required time-investment. When I do find the right questionnaire, i'll be sure to let you know.

The online ACEs toolkit you describe sounds highly interesting. I'd very much like to hear how far you've come with this project, and where i can find the current version of the toolkit (if available)?

Best,
Tim

@Jamie Lancaster: I am autistic, and I find myself feeling a little annoyed about "lack of eye contact" being on the list you presented. I know it's unintentional, but from my perspective it felt like an insult.

See, autistic people like me are stereotyped as "callous" and "unempathetic" because we have difficulty making eye contact and don't understand facial expressions. When we understand other people's feelings, we can sympathize and want to help; it's getting the understanding in the first place that's the problem.

To me, it feels like being the only non-psychic in a society full of telepaths. If I say I don't understand telepathy, everyone starts talking very loudly and slowly as if I was a foreigner, even though I understand speech fine. (And most of them are backchatting through telepathy saying I'm stupid and slow, and quickly move away from me.)

To be entirely fair to you, if you're measuring entirely for face to face interactions between people who are usually not autistic, using eye contact as an indicator makes sense. But that hit a nerve: just because I'm not capable of empathy-A doesn't mean I'm not capable of empathy-B, and I'm kind of sick of being called a sociopath for it.

You don't really need to reply to this if you don't want to, and I'm not asking for any reply; I just had some strong feelings on the topic and needed to unpack them.

Last edited by Elaine Wang
Elaine Wang posted:

@Jamie Lancaster: I am autistic, and I find myself feeling a little annoyed about "lack of eye contact" being on the list you presented. I know it's unintentional, but from my perspective it felt like an insult.

See, autistic people like me are stereotyped as "callous" and "unempathetic" because we have difficulty making eye contact and don't understand facial expressions. When we understand other people's feelings, we can sympathize and want to help; it's getting the understanding in the first place that's the problem.

To me, it feels like being the only non-psychic in a society full of telepaths. If I say I don't understand telepathy, everyone starts talking very loudly and slowly as if I was a foreigner, even though I understand speech fine. (And most of them are backchatting through telepathy saying I'm stupid and slow, and quickly move away from me.)

To be entirely fair to you, if you're measuring entirely for face to face interactions between people who are usually not autistic, using eye contact as an indicator makes sense. But that hit a nerve: just because I'm not capable of empathy-A doesn't mean I'm not capable of empathy-B, and I'm kind of sick of being called a sociopath for it.

You don't really need to reply to this if you don't want to, and I'm not asking for any reply; I just had some strong feelings on the topic and needed to unpack them.

Dear Elaine,

I am so sorry that you were annoyed by my comment. This was not my intent. I'm glad that you shared your feelings with me and others on this post. We all need to be educated on the feelings of others and widen out our perspectives. So I think you for educating me. I'm sure that  if I met you in person I would not feel that you were not empathetic. I have friends that are Autistic and have found that they have their way of communicating and I enjoy being with them.

I have also spent most of my adult life with the Deaf community where facial expressions have much of the meaning for sign language users. I also had to learn to modify my signing to fit the needs of the Deaf and Blind. So I'm still learning. 

Thank you for sharing your perspective with me.

PS Can you enlighten me on empathy-B?

Add Reply

Copyright ÂĐ 2023, PACEsConnection. All rights reserved.
×
×
×
×
Link copied to your clipboard.
×